C3A and C3B Voting -- C3A Voting Results

C3A Changes

As a result of the voting by the members of the CALLERLAB Challenge Committee who actively call C3A...

The following changes have been made to the C3A list (February 2000):

Dropped
- Rolling Ripple
- Shove Off
Added
- Finally Concept
- Reverse Crazy Concept
Renamed
- Split | Box Checkmate to Single Checkmate

Methodology

Votes were solicited from CALLERLAB members via postal mailing, and from dancers and callers via the web. However, only votes by CALLERLAB members actively calling C3A were used for the final determination. The other votes were helpful in resolving close votes and identifying situations that required further reconsideration.

Guidelines for final determination:
- To drop a call, 50% is needed
- To add a call, 66% is needed
- To rename a call, there was no set guideline. We (CALLERLAB Challenge Committee Chairman Ed Foote, and Vice-Chairman Vic Ceder) reviewed the voting results and made an executive decision to rename the call.

Details

Legend:

Change to C3A list

No change

CALLERLAB votes

non-CALLERLAB votes

Total votes

Patch (anyone)

Drop:

33%

(8)

Drop:

30%

(14)

Drop:

31%

(22)

Keep:

67%

(16)

Keep:

70%

(32)

Keep:

69%

(48)

Peel Chain Thru

Drop:

33%

(8)

Drop:

33%

(15)

Drop:

33%

(23)

Keep:

67%

(16)

Keep:

67%

(31)

Keep:

67%

(47)

Rolling Ripple

Drop:

63%

(15)

Drop:

61%

(28)

Drop:

61%

(43)

Keep:

38%

(9)

Keep:

39%

(18)

Keep:

39%

(27)

Shove Off

Drop:

54%

(13)

Drop:

59%

(27)

Drop:

57%

(40)

Keep:

46%

(11)

Keep:

41%

(19)

Keep:

43%

(30)

Slant anything By anything

Drop:

42%

(10)

Drop:

51%

(23)

Drop:

48%

(33)

Keep:

58%

(14)

Keep:

49%

(22)

Keep:

52%

(36)

Switch Your Leader

Drop:

46%

(11)

Drop:

53%

(25)

Drop:

51%

(36)

Keep:

54%

(13)

Keep:

47%

(22)

Keep:

49%

(35)

Wrap to a formation

Drop:

29%

(7)

Drop:

20%

(9)

Drop:

23%

(16)

Keep:

71%

(17)

Keep:

80%

(37)

Keep:

77%

(54)

Cross Extend

Add:

42%

(10)

Add:

59%

(27)

Add:

53%

(37)

Don't Add:

58%

(14)

Don't Add:

41%

(19)

Don't Add:

47%

(33)

Cross Follow Thru

Add:

38%

(9)

Add:

47%

(22)

Add:

44%

(31)

Don't Add:

63%

(15)

Don't Add:

53%

(25)

Don't Add:

56%

(40)

Cross Wind The Bobbin

Add:

46%

(11)

Add:

40%

(19)

Add:

42%

(30)

Don't Add:

54%

(13)

Don't Add:

60%

(28)

Don't Add:

58%

(41)

Fan Concept

Add:

54%

(13)

Add:

66%

(31)

Add:

62%

(44)

Don't Add:

46%

(11)

Don't Add:

34%

(16)

Don't Add:

38%

(27)

Finally Concept

Add:

71%

(17)

Add:

82%

(37)

Add:

78%

(54)

Don't Add:

29%

(7)

Don't Add:

18%

(8)

Don't Add:

22%

(15)

Quadruple formation

Add:

50%

(12)

Add:

57%

(26)

Add:

54%

(38)

Don't Add:

50%

(12)

Don't Add:

43%

(20)

Don't Add:

46%

(32)

Reverse Crazy Concept

Add:

71%

(17)

Add:

77%

(36)

Add:

75%

(53)

Don't Add:

29%

(7)

Don't Add:

23%

(11)

Don't Add:

25%

(18)

Tag Back and Dodge, Tag Chain Thru and Dodge

Add:

42%

(10)

Add:

44%

(20)

Add:

43%

(30)

Don't Add:

58%

(14)

Don't Add:

56%

(25)

Don't Add:

57%

(39)

Track n

Add:

54%

(13)

Add:

70%

(33)

Add:

65%

(46)

Don't Add:

46%

(11)

Don't Add:

30%

(14)

Don't Add:

35%

(25)

Transaction

Add:

38%

(9)

Add:

65%

(30)

Add:

56%

(39)

Don't Add:

63%

(15)

Don't Add:

35%

(16)

Don't Add:

44%

(31)

Twisted Concept

Add:

17%

(4)

Add:

26%

(12)

Add:

23%

(16)

Don't Add:

83%

(20)

Don't Add:

74%

(35)

Don't Add:

77%

(55)

"Uncomplicated" Twosomes

Add:

38%

(9)

Add:

45%

(21)

Add:

42%

(30)

Don't Add:

63%

(15)

Don't Add:

55%

(26)

Don't Add:

58%

(41)

Rename Split Checkmate to Single Checkmate?

Rename:

57%

(13)

Rename:

78%

(35)

Rename:

71%

(48)

Don't Rename:

43%

(10)

Don't Rename:

22%

(10)

Don't Rename:

29%

(20)

Once Removed Diamonds

Drop:

18%

(4)

Drop:

33%

(14)

Drop:

28%

(18)

Keep:

82%

(18)

Keep:

67%

(29)

Keep:

72%

(47)